Reporters Without Borders has published its second world press freedom ranking. Like last year, the most catastrophic situation is to be found in Asia, with eight countries in the bottom ten: North Korea, Burma, Laos, China, Iran, Vietnam, Turkmenistan and Bhutan. South Africa ranked 21st.
Independent news media are either non-existent in these countries, or are constantly repressed by the authorities. Journalists there work in extremely difficult conditions, with no freedom and no security. A number of them are imprisoned in Burma, China and Iran.
Cuba is in 165th position, second from last. Twenty-six independent journalists were arrested in the spring of 2003 and sentenced to prison terms ranging from 14 to 27 years, making Cuba the world's biggest prison for journalists. They were accused of writing articles for publication abroad that played into the hands of "imperialist interests." Eritrea, in 162nd position, has the worst situation in Africa. Privately-owned news media have been banned there for the past two years and 14 journalists are being held in undisclosed locations.
To compile this ranking, Reporters Without Borders asked journalists, researchers, jurists and human rights activists to fill out a questionnaire evaluating respect for press freedom in a particular country. A total of 166 countries are included in the ranking (as against 139 last year). The other countries were left out because of a lack of reliable, well-supported data.
Wealth and press freedom don't always go together As in 2002, the ranking shows that a country's respect for press freedom is not solely linked to its economic development. The top 50 include countries that are among the poorest in the world, such as Benin (29th position), Timor-Leste (30th) and Madagascar (46th).
Conversely, the 50 countries that respect press freedom least include such rich nations as Bahrain (117th) and Singapore (144th).
News is the victim of war in Africa Wars and serious political crises have inevitably had an impact on press freedom in Africa. The three countries that have fallen most in the ranking in the past 12 months are Côte d'Ivoire (137th), Liberia (132nd) and Guinea-Bissau (118th). Local and foreign journalists were exposed to the violence of the warring parties in Côte d'Ivoire and Liberia, while the military closed down news media in Guinea-Bissau.
World press freedom ranking
N°
Country
Note
1
Finland
0,50
-
Iceland
0,50
-
Netherlands
0,50
-
Norway
0,50
5
Denmark
1,00
-
Trinidad and Tobago
1,00
7
Belgium
1,17
8
Germany
1,33
9
Sweden
1,50
10
Canada
1,83
11
Latvia
2,25
12
Czech Republic
2,50
-
Estonia
2,50
-
Slovakia
2,50
-
Switzerland
2,50
16
Austria
2,75
17
Ireland
2,83
-
Lithuania
2,83
-
New Zealand
2,83
20
Slovenia
3,00
21
Hungary
3,33
-
Jamaica
3,33
-
South Africa
3,33
24
Costa Rica
3,83
25
Uruguay
4,00
26
France
4,17
27
United Kingdom
4,25
28
Portugal
5,17
29
Benin
5,25
30
Timor-Leste
5,50
31
Greece
6,00
-
United States of America (American territory)
6,00
33
Poland
6,17
34
Albania
6,50
-
Bulgaria
6,50
-
Nicaragua
6,50
37
Bosnia and Herzegovina
6,83
-
Chile
6,83
-
El Salvador
6,83
40
Paraguay
7,17
41
Mauritius
7,25
42
Ecuador
7,67
-
Spain
7,67
44
Israel (Israeli territory)
8,00
-
Japan
8,00
46
Madagascar
8,17
47
Cape Verde
8,25
48
Ghana
8,75
49
South Korea
9,17
50
Australia
9,25
51
Bolivia
9,67
-
Macedonia
9,67
53
Italy
9,75
-
Panama
9,75
55
Peru
10,25
56
Hong-Kong
11,00
-
Mali
11,00
-
Namibia
11,00
59
Fiji
11,50
-
Romania
11,50
61
Taïwan
12,00
62
Botswana
13,00
63
Congo
14,00
-
Mozambique
14,00
65
Honduras
14,17
66
Senegal
14,50
67
Argentina
15,17
68
Niger
15,75
69
Croatia
16,50
-
Tanzania
16,50
71
Brazil
16,75
72
Dominican Republic
17,00
73
Georgia
17,33
74
Mexico
17,67
75
Lesotho
17,75
76
Burkina Faso
18,00
77
Gambia
18,25
-
Mongolia
18,25
79
Comoros
18,50
-
Kenya
18,50
81
Cambodia
19,50
82
Thailand
19,67
83
Cyprus
20,83
84
Malawi
21,00
85
Serbia and Montenegro
21,33
86
Zambia
23,25
87
Sierra Leone
23,50
88
Chad
24,00
89
Sri Lanka
24,83
90
Armenia
25,17
91
Uganda
25,75
92
Burundi
26,25
93
Seychelles
26,75
94
Moldova
27,00
95
Togo
27,50
96
Venezuela
27,83
97
Angola
28,00
98
Cameroon
30,50
99
Guatemala
30,83
100
Haiti
31,00
101
Gabon
31,25
102
Kuwait
31,33
103
Nigeria
31,50
104
Kyrgyzstan
32,00
-
Malaysia
32,00
106
Lebanon
32,50
107
Central African Republic
32,75
108
Algeria
33,00
109
Guinea
33,17
110
Egypt
34,25
-
Indonesia
34,25
-
Rwanda
34,25
113
Azerbaijan
34,50
-
Tajikistan
34,50
115
Qatar
35,00
-
Turkey
35,00
117
Bahrain
35,17
118
Guinea-Bissau
35,25
-
Philippines
35,25
120
Djibouti
35,50
121
Mauritania
36,67
122
United Arab Emirates
37,00
-
Jordan
37,00
124
Ethiopia
37,50
-
Iraq
37,50
-
Swaziland
37,50
127
Democratic Republic of Congo
38,50
128
India
39,00
-
Pakistan
39,00
130
Palestinian Authority
39,25
131
Morocco
39,67
132
Liberia
40,00
-
Ukraine
40,00
134
Afghanistan
40,17
135
United States of America (in Iraq)
41,00
136
Yemen
41,83
137
Côte d'Ivoire
42,17
138
Kazakhstan
42,50
139
Equatorial Guinea
44,75
140
Somalia
45,00
141
Zimbabwe
45,50
142
Sudan
45,75
143
Bangladesh
46,50
144
Singapore
47,33
145
Maldives
47,50
146
Israel (Occupied Territories)
49,00
147
Colombia
49,17
148
Russia
49,50
149
Tunisia
50,83
150
Nepal
51,50
151
Belarus
52,00
152
Oman
57,75
153
Libya
60,00
154
Uzbekistan
61,50
155
Syria
67,50
156
Saudi Arabia
71,50
157
Bhutan
77,33
158
Turkmenistan
82,83
159
Vietnam
89,17
160
Iran
89,33
161
China
91,25
162
Eritrea
91,50
163
Laos
94,83
164
Burma
95,50
165
Cuba
97,83
166
North Korea
99,50
How the ranking was compiled This ranking measures the state of press freedom in the world. It reflects the degree of freedom that journalists and news organisations enjoy in each country, and the efforts undertaken by the state to respect and ensure respect for this freedom.
It is a snapshot of the situation in a precise period. It only takes account of events between 1 September 2002 and 1 September 2003. It does not look at human rights violations in general, just press freedom violations.
To compile this ranking, Reporters Without Borders designed a questionnaire with 53 criteria for assessing the state of press freedom in each country. It includes every kind of violation directly affecting journalists (such as murders, imprisonment, physical attacks and threats) and news media (censorship, confiscation of issues, searches and harassment). It registers the degree of impunity enjoyed by those responsible for these press freedom violations. It takes account of the legal and judicial situation affecting the news media (such as the penalties for press offences, the existence of a state monopoly in certain areas and the existence of a regulatory body) and the behaviour of the authorities towards the state-owned news media and international press. It also takes account of the main obstacles to the free flow of information on the Internet.
Reporters Without Borders has taken account not only of abuses attributable to the state, but also those by armed militia, clandestine organisations or pressure groups that can pose a real threat to press freedom.
The questionnaire was sent to people who have a deep knowledge of the state of press freedom in a country or a number of countries: local journalists or foreign reporters based in a country, researchers, jurists, regional specialists and the researchers working for Reporters Without Borders' International Secretariat.
The countries that were ranked are those for which Reporters Without Borders received completed questionnaires from a number of independent sources. Others were not included because of a lack of reliable, well-supported input. In cases of ties, countries were ranked by alphabetical order.
Finally, in no case should this ranking be viewed as an indication of the quality of the press in the countries concerned. Reporters Without Borders defends press freedom, without taking a position on the quality of the editorial content of the news media. No account was taken of any breaches of professional ethics or codes of conduct.
Editorial contact Reporters sans Frontières (Paris) Bureau Afrique-Africa Desk 5 Tel: 33 1 44 83 84 84